I Read a Lot of Books

By Stephen Casimiro

All books / the mind

The Case Against Reality

Donald D. Hoffman / 2022 / 280 pages

Donald Hoffman is a cognitive scientist who ran evolutionary simulations and got a result he didn’t like: Organisms that perceive reality accurately lose to organisms that perceive fitness payoffs instead. His conclusion is that space, time, and objects are a species-specific interface — like icons on a computer desktop, they are useful but not literally true. The desktop metaphor carries the book: A file icon isn’t what’s inside the computer, but you’d be a fool to drag it to the trash. Then he goes further than most readers will follow, into consciousness as fundamental. Take the first half as a serious argument about perception and the second half as speculation. Of course, when it comes to the nature of consciousness, it’s all speculation.

No ads, no sponsors, no paid posts. I Read a Lot of Books runs entirely on reader support, your purchases of Long Weekend Coffee, and a small commission on books you buy through Bookshop.org.

WHERE I AM WITH IT

Want to read Still reading Didn’t finish Read

Filed under the mind and essay.

The Case Against Reality

W.W. Norton & Company / 2022 / 280 pages

Get my newsletter

Field Notes from a Very Cool World.

Generally monthly. I hope the title says it all.