I Read a Lot of Books

By Stephen Casimiro

All books / Northeast

Heather

Caitlin & Mullen / 2026 / 352 pages

Callie Hauser comes home to the New Jersey Pine Barrens as the new police chief, which in a town this size means everybody she polices knew her as a kid. She makes an arrest that looks routine and it kicks loose a case nobody has touched, or will touch, in thirty years: The Riley girls, twins and sixteen years old, disappeared one day in the nineties without a trace. Author Caitlin Mullen, who won the 2021 Edgar Award for Best First Novel for Please See Us, braids two timelines, the girls then and Callie now, and one of the voices comes at you in second person, which takes some getting used to and then gets under your skin. It’s slow on purpose. Mullen lives in Jersey, and the creepy Pine Barrens do a lot of the work — a million-plus acres of scrub pine and sand roads and stories, right in the middle of the most crowded state in the country.

No ads, no sponsors, no paid posts. I Read a Lot of Books runs entirely on reader support, your purchases of Long Weekend Coffee, and a small commission on books you buy through Bookshop.org.

WHERE I AM WITH IT

Want to read Still reading Didn’t finish Read

Filed under crime, thriller, and Northeast.

Heather

Celadon Books / 2026 / 352 pages

Get my newsletter

Field Notes from a Very Cool World.

Generally monthly. I hope the title says it all.